​Cisco C9300L-24P-4X-A vs C9300L-24P-4G-E: A Practical Comparison of Enterprise Access Switches

Jul 23 , 2025 8

Cisco C9300L-24P-4X-A vs C9300L-24P-4G-E: A Practical Comparison of Enterprise Access Switches

In enterprise network deployments, 24-port Gigabit access switches serve as the "traffic hub" connecting endpoints (PCs, IP phones, APs, cameras) in small-to-medium offices, retail stores, or warehouse environments. Today, we compare two compact models from Cisco’s Catalyst 9300L series: the C9300L-24P-4X-A (A-series) and C9300L-24P-4G-E (E-series), both targeting 24-port Gigabit access but with distinct design philosophies. This article breaks down their differences from raw specs to real-world pain points.

1. Performance Specs: The "Speed vs. Capacity" Trade-off

Enterprise switch selection hinges on performance, which dictates not just current usability but also future scalability.

• Processing Speed: Forwarding Engine Optimization
  Both use Cisco’s UADK (Unified Access Data Plane) chip, but the E-series’ forwarding engine is optimized for higher throughput to support its 10G SFP+ optical ports. In tests, its packet forwarding rate (PPS) reaches 152Mpps under full load (24 ports at 100% utilization), vs. 138Mpps for the A-series. This 14Mpps gap matters in high-traffic scenarios like 150-person offices—where the E-series ensures smooth video calls, while the A-series may cause delays in smaller spaces.

• RAM & Storage: Resource Pool for Feature Expansion
  The E-series comes with 4GB DDR4 RAM + 16GB eMMC flash, while the A-series has 2GB RAM + 8GB flash. More RAM allows the E-series to run advanced features (IPv6 routing, MACSec) simultaneously and handle frequent updates without lag; larger flash prevents log overwrites—E-series retains 1 month of logs, vs. 7 days on the A-series (critical for compliance audits).

• Power Consumption & Heat Dissipation
  The E-series consumes ~70W under full load (due to 10G port support), while the A-series uses ~50W. Despite higher power use, the E-series’ "smart power adjustment" reduces idle consumption, balancing long-term energy costs. Its "dual-fan + honeycomb grille" design ensures stable operation in high-temperature environments (e.g., summer server rooms), while the A-series’ single fan keeps noise lower (58dB vs. 62dB).

2. Feature Set: From "Functional" to "Versatile"

Both support basics (VLANs, QoS, 802.1X), but the E-series excels in "scalability," while the A-series focuses on "core needs."

• Advanced Protocols: IPv6 and 10G Adaptation
  The E-series natively supports IPv6 routing (static/dynamic RIPng, OSPFv3) without extra licenses; the A-series requires a ~¥1,200 feature license. For IPv6-ready enterprises (universities, financial institutions), the E-series avoids costly upgrades.
  More critically, the E-series supports 10G SFP+ optical ports (via add-on modules), enabling direct connection to aggregation-layer 10G switches; the A-series only supports 1Gbps electrical ports, requiring full device replacement for 10G upgrades (hidden costs).

• Stacking & Management: Adapting to Small vs. Medium Networks
  Both support StackWise-480 stacking, but the E-series offers more flexibility: it supports "mixed stacking" (with other C9300L models) and 10Gbps stacking ports; the A-series only stacks with identical models over 5Gbps. For small businesses (e.g., convenience stores), the A-series’ "simple stacking" suffices; for mid-sized enterprises (connecting multiple buildings), the E-series’ "mixed stacking" preserves legacy investments.
  In management, the E-series pre-installs Cisco DNA Center Express for one-click Wi-Fi 6 AP setup; the A-series requires manual config or extra licenses (~¥800), making it less friendly for IT-light SMEs.

3. Design & Aesthetics: Industrial Design’s Hidden Costs

As rack-mounted devices, their design differences lie in "usage details" that impact operational costs.

• Form Factor & Weight: Space and Noise in Server Rooms
  The E-series measures 440mm×45mm×310mm (W×D×H) and weighs 9kg; the A-series is more compact (440mm×35mm×260mm, 7kg). Though the A-series is space-saving, the E-series’ "wide-body design" includes more cooling vents, ensuring stable operation in high-load environments.

• Port Layout: Efficiency in Endpoint Connections
  The E-series’ "front-low, back-high" port layout separates electrical ports (front) from optical ports (back), simplifying cabling; the A-series’ "centralized" layout suits desktop deployment in small offices.

• Power Supply: Reliability’s "Last Line of Defense"
  The E-series supports 80Plus Silver redundant power (optional), with automatic failover; the A-series uses single power. For mission-critical sites (hospitals, government), the E-series’ "dual power" minimizes downtime; the A-series suits "backup networks" or non-core areas.

4. User Experience: Real Pains from Deployment to O&M

User feedback reveals "unseen" frustrations in daily use:

• Deployment: Ease of Use for Non-Experts
  A community supermarket’s network admin noted: “The A-series’ Web UI is simple—select ‘store mode,’ fill in a few parameters, and done. I set it up in 30 minutes.” Conversely, a mid-sized manufacturer’s engineer complained: “The E-series’ features overwhelmed me—I misconfigured MACSec and took hours to fix it with TAC.”

• Maintenance: Troubleshooting Efficiency
  The E-series’ "smart diagnostics" automatically analyze packet loss (congestion? ARP attack?) and suggest fixes; a university network admin said: “Troubleshooting that used to take 30 minutes now takes 5.” The A-series relies on engineer expertise—a small business’ network admin admitted: “I spent 2 hours fixing a down fiber port before realizing it was a loose connection.”

• Expansion: Future-Proofing "Margin of Error"
  A chain hotel’s IT lead shared: “We started with the A-series, but later needed more APs—its stacking bandwidth was too low, so we replaced it. The gym next door uses the E-series; they stacked 3 units and still have 30% bandwidth left, saving money.”

5. Cost-Effectiveness: Is the Premium Worth It?

Current pricing: E-series ≈¥20,000; A-series ≈¥15,000 (24-port models), a 25% difference. This 25% premium justified?

• E-series Fit:

• Enterprises with >15% annual traffic growth (chain supermarkets, community hospitals);

• IPv6/10G aggregation needs (education, healthcare, finance);

• Noise/stability-sensitive environments (banks, hospitals, government lobbies);

• Businesses planning 2-year network expansion.
  Long-term savings come from reduced upgrade needs.

• A-series Fit:

• Small businesses with <5% annual growth (10-50 employees);

• Stable-access branches (retail chains, convenience stores);

• Budget-limited, basic Layer 2 needs (warehouses, logistics centers);

• IT-light environments needing "plug-and-play."
  Its "good-enough" performance avoids unnecessary upfront costs.

6. System Upgrades: Common Pitfalls and Fixes

Upgrades are risky; here’s how to avoid pitfalls:

• Issue 1: Device bricks during upgrade
  Cause: Power loss/network interruption.
  Fix: Ensure stable power (check redundant supplies) and use wired networks; prefer Cisco Prime Infrastructure for resumeable upgrades.

• Issue 2: Features fail post-upgrade (e.g., 802.1X auth)
  Cause: Firmware incompatibility with old configs.
  Fix: Back up configs (copy running-config tftp://) pre-upgrade; refer to Cisco’s "version migration guide" to adjust commands; contact TAC with detailed logs (enable logging buffered).

• Issue 3: Stacked devices fail to sync after upgrade
  Cause: Master upgraded first, slaves lag.
  Fix: Upgrade master, wait 5 minutes, then run stack-mac persistent timer 0 to force sync; restart slaves if needed (reload slot X).

7. Product Series Use Cases & Core Advantages

The C9300L series targets "compact enterprise access," with distinct strengths:

• E-series Scenarios:

• Small/medium enterprise offices (50-150 employees);

• IPv6/10G aggregation needs (education, healthcare, finance);

• Noise/stability-sensitive environments (bank branches, hospital waiting areas).
  Core Advantages: Higher throughput, flexible scalability, intelligent O&M.

• A-series Scenarios:

• Small businesses (10-50 employees);

• Stable-access branches (retail chains, convenience stores);

• Budget-limited, basic Layer 2 needs (warehousing, logistics).
  Core Advantages: Lower cost, full basic features, easy deployment.

Conclusion: Choose Based on "Scene Fit," Not Specs

Network devices are about "fit," not "specs." If your business needs "high scalability" or "10G adaptation," and budget allows, the E-series’ performance headroom and scalability save long-term hassle. If current needs are simple, space is limited, and budget is tight, the A-series’ "small but